Debate: Obamacare
Debate: Obamacare
    • Report this story folder
Debate: Obamacare
Everyone has a story to tell
Find the best stories to read and people to follow. Get inspired and start writing great stories yourself or with your friends. Share and let the world know.

Why we need the disastrous Obamacare to fail

Why we need the disastrous Obamacare to fail
Collaborate with friends on topics you love
Request co-authorship ▸

When Congress failed to repeal the Affordable Care Act last month, President Donald Trump unleashed these hard-hitting words:

“I think we're probably in that position where we'll let Obamacare fail,” he said. “We're not going to own it. I'm not going to own it. I can tell you the Republicans are not going to own it. We'll let Obamacare fail and then the Democrats are going to come to us.”

Trump, who has called the ACA a “disaster” on multiple occasions, cites high deductibles, high premiums and health insurers leaving the healthcare exchange.

The ACA is in a death spiral, Republicans and others have said. A death spiral occurs when the options available to customers are too few and too expensive, so healthy customers opt not to purchase insurance, leaving only the sick to share costs.

Death Spiral Imminent

Earlier this year, Aetna CEO Mark Bertolini proclaimed the ACA is in a death spiral because too many ill were entering the exchange, raising insurer costs. This will force insurers to leave the market or take a loss in the markets, he said.

"There isn't enough money in the ACA today as it is structured – even with its fees and taxes – to support the population that needs to be served," Bertolini said.

An estimated 1 percent to 5 percent of Aetna’s customers share half the cost.

Insurers are expected to receive an estimated $7 billion from the federal government this year in cost-sharing reductions meant to defray the costs of insuring lower income customers.

So far this year, enrollment in unsubsidized plans during open enrollment has decreased 29 percent compared to the past four years. These individuals are paying their full insurance premiums out of pocket.

According to a report by Mike Farrah and Associates, the number of Americans insured through the individual insurance market dropped 13 percent to 17.6 million between March 2016 and March 2017. Of these people, 5.4 million opted to purchase their coverage off the exchange.

The report also found that 2.4 million people only have one healthcare plan option on the exchange. Last year, 227 qualified health plans had filed initial applications to offer coverage. This year, the number has dropped 38 percent to 141.

“This is further proof that the Affordable Care Act is failing,” said CMS Administrator Seema Verma. “Insurers continue to flee the Exchanges, causing Americans to lose their choice for health insurance or lose their coverage all together. These numbers are clear: the status quo is not working. The American people deserve healthcare choices and access to quality, affordable healthcare coverage.”

Republicans Against ACA

Republicans have been against ACA from the beginning. In 2011, the Republican National Committee posted in its website, “Obamacare and its unconstitutional mandate drives up health care costs, increases insurance premiums, hurts the quality of health care, raises taxes, and blows up the deficit.”

This view is still held by the GOP. Their arguments include:

Costs will go up not down and people won’t be able to keep their doctors.

•Insuring more Americans will create a shortage of physicians and this will lead to longer wait times for service or doctors refusing patients.

•Emergency rooms will become more crowded from people seeking care.

•Small businesses receive penalties if they do not provide insurance to their employees.

•The federal debt will increase.

There is one other argument favored among Republicans, most vocally Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY), and that is the idea that the ACA is an entitlement program and that the federal government has no business insuring its citizens. Paul has said he will vote against any bill, even one proposed by his own party, if it’s an entitlement program.

Clearly, healthcare is a subject that is personal for many people, and illness and injury are events no one can escape. How and when the ACA dies is anyone’s guess, but its demise will effect every American.

When do you think ACA will hit rock bottom?

Photo credit:

Allowing Obamacare to implode is a horrible and costly idea

Allowing Obamacare to implode is a horrible and costly idea
Collaborate with friends on topics you love
Request co-authorship ▸

“Let Obamacare fail and then everybody is going to have to come together and fix it.”

That’s what a disappointed President Trump said on July 18 after the Senate failed to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act.

If you are one of the people who thought that was a good idea, I’m sorry to disappoint you, but apparently even Trump now believes that’s a dumb idea.

Just two weeks later, on August 6, the President told a rally in West Virginia, “Congress must do its job, keep its promise, live up to its word, and repeal and replace Obamacare. You have to do it.”

Here we go again.

Right now there are no good answers, but allowing Obamacare to implode is the worst one for several reasons.

First and foremost, voters elected Trump on the promise he would repeal and replace Obamacare. Sometimes he would add “on day one.”

The Republicans have been promising to repeal and replace for seven years. Several times a year, the Republican Congress would send a bill to replace Obamacare to the White House, with the knowledge that President Obama would veto it.

To give up the fight now, would be embarrassing to the president, but especially to Congress, who’s past repeal legislation now looks suspiciously disingenuous.

Allowing Obamacare to implode is a horrible and costly idea

Not to mention the fact, that premiums and deductibles continue to exponentially rise. The middle class and small businesses, the core of Trump’s support, are especially feeling the pain of a failing healthcare system. To walk away now and ignore that pain, after using it to win the House, the Senate, and the White House, is not only heartless, but political suicide.

There is, of course, a third option. Republicans could work with Democrats to fix the Affordable Care Act and make it more affordable. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has already signaled his willingness to take that route, if he believes the repeal and replace effort is dead.

In truth, the fight in Congress never really was about repeal and replace, but naming rights. Republicans wanted to rename The Affordable Care Act with the American Health Care Act; Obamacare with Trumpcare.

Trump has a long history of wanting to put his name on things.

No matter what you call it, the massive entitlement of government run health care would still exist. The Republican leadership surrendered that fight at the start of the session.

Allowing Obamacare to implode is a horrible and costly idea

Look for Republicans to make one more effort to repeal and replace Obamacare in the fall. But if they can’t get moderates and conservatives in their party to agree, leadership will reach out to Democrats and Obamacare will live on, with an increase in subsidies to insurance company to bring down premiums.

If that happens, Trumps prediction that “everybody is going to come together to fix it” will come true, with the notable exception that Barack Obama still gets the naming rights. 

You've read the story folder
Story cover
written by
Writer avatar
Emmy Award-winning TV anchor and reporter, radio talk show host, political junkie, media critic and proud father of four.